June 10, 2007
This may be an esoteric topic and discussion for some. It is relevant to the management and proper operation of the non-profit corporation, which our HOA is under the Texas Non-Profit Corporation Act which chartered it, as well as the legality of using properly formed proxy documents related to execution of business of the HOA.
I put it here for any who want to track the discussion.
I sent this email to Marisela De Leon, property manager, with copy to Gil Vipraio, President and member of Board of Directors (BOD) of the HOA.
Hi Marisela,
Once when I asked for a bylaws compliant proxy from the HOA you told me over the phone that no proxies are issued until there is a
call for a meeting, an annual meeting or special meeting of the members.
First, has this policy/procedure (been prior) written and approved by the BOD? If so I would like to obtain it as soon as possible.
Second, I am not so sure what this procedure comports with the by-laws, as the latter does not constrain when or where or how
proxies are created, prepared, distributed. The only inherent constraints I read are:
(1) they must be revocable.
(2) they must not expire any sooner than 11 months from assignment unless member sells Parkwood property before then.
(3) they are presented to the Secretary (filed) at a meeting.
This then indicates to me:
(1) a proxy may be assigned (signed) at any time.
(2) a proxy may be revoked at any time before it expires.
(3) a proxy expires as specified by the bylaws and not by the BOD.
(4) a proxy does not have to specify a particular event, and thus may indicate all annual, special meetings for the duration of
the instrument.
(5) a proxy may constrain or may not constrain the voting rights assigned by the member to the holder.
(6) filing a proxy with the Secretary does not constrain the applicability of the proxy to any single event, meeting, or action.
Third, I do know the proxies created lately associated with the last two annual meetings violated the bylaws on points already
pointed out to you, the BOD. I have asked for a valid response from the BOD about this, and it has failed to do so (remember my
September 17, 2006 and March 14, 2007 email requests, for example).
Fourth, please cause a generic proxy compliant with the bylaws, not constraining voting rights a member may assign the proxy holder,
not constraining the purpose or purposes of the assignment to any action or event, and specifically indicate its modes of
expiration. If you wish to add information to the proxy it should offer selections for different types of meetings, petitions, and
assignment of voting authority (scope, constraint, full breadth of issues to come before the membership for a vote).
Please email me a draft of this proxy at least 10 days before any proxies are to be distributed associated with the July 2007 annual
meeting (also prescribed by the bylaws).
I believe that if the HOA BOD does not issue a bylaws compliant proxy, it will be challenged as illegal at this meeting, as it was
challenged as non-compliant with the bylaws at the September 2006 annual meeting (which the minutes should so reflect).
Opinion: (Removed).
Thanks,
Your responses will be posted at the web site.
Regards,
Mike McCormack
Anyone else interested in seeing what Marisela/BOD sends me, let me know.
-By Mike McCormack
This may be an esoteric topic and discussion for some. It is relevant to the management and proper operation of the non-profit corporation, which our HOA is under the Texas Non-Profit Corporation Act which chartered it, as well as the legality of using properly formed proxy documents related to execution of business of the HOA.
I put it here for any who want to track the discussion.
I sent this email to Marisela De Leon, property manager, with copy to Gil Vipraio, President and member of Board of Directors (BOD) of the HOA.
Hi Marisela,
Once when I asked for a bylaws compliant proxy from the HOA you told me over the phone that no proxies are issued until there is a
call for a meeting, an annual meeting or special meeting of the members.
First, has this policy/procedure (been prior) written and approved by the BOD? If so I would like to obtain it as soon as possible.
Second, I am not so sure what this procedure comports with the by-laws, as the latter does not constrain when or where or how
proxies are created, prepared, distributed. The only inherent constraints I read are:
(1) they must be revocable.
(2) they must not expire any sooner than 11 months from assignment unless member sells Parkwood property before then.
(3) they are presented to the Secretary (filed) at a meeting.
This then indicates to me:
(1) a proxy may be assigned (signed) at any time.
(2) a proxy may be revoked at any time before it expires.
(3) a proxy expires as specified by the bylaws and not by the BOD.
(4) a proxy does not have to specify a particular event, and thus may indicate all annual, special meetings for the duration of
the instrument.
(5) a proxy may constrain or may not constrain the voting rights assigned by the member to the holder.
(6) filing a proxy with the Secretary does not constrain the applicability of the proxy to any single event, meeting, or action.
Third, I do know the proxies created lately associated with the last two annual meetings violated the bylaws on points already
pointed out to you, the BOD. I have asked for a valid response from the BOD about this, and it has failed to do so (remember my
September 17, 2006 and March 14, 2007 email requests, for example).
Fourth, please cause a generic proxy compliant with the bylaws, not constraining voting rights a member may assign the proxy holder,
not constraining the purpose or purposes of the assignment to any action or event, and specifically indicate its modes of
expiration. If you wish to add information to the proxy it should offer selections for different types of meetings, petitions, and
assignment of voting authority (scope, constraint, full breadth of issues to come before the membership for a vote).
Please email me a draft of this proxy at least 10 days before any proxies are to be distributed associated with the July 2007 annual
meeting (also prescribed by the bylaws).
I believe that if the HOA BOD does not issue a bylaws compliant proxy, it will be challenged as illegal at this meeting, as it was
challenged as non-compliant with the bylaws at the September 2006 annual meeting (which the minutes should so reflect).
Opinion: (Removed).
Thanks,
Your responses will be posted at the web site.
Regards,
Mike McCormack
Anyone else interested in seeing what Marisela/BOD sends me, let me know.
-By Mike McCormack